Criminals from the king's prisons
Celsus tells, some three centuries later, that the kings handed Herophilus and Erasistratus condemned criminals from their prisons to cut open alive, as the physicians who defended the practice claimed; Tertullian, around 210 CE, says Herophilus dissected six hundred people.
Told by Celsus, c. 30 CE, some three centuries later
What the evidence supports
Herophilus's anatomical discoveries in Alexandria are attested in Galen and others, and human dissection there is generally accepted. Celsus passes on the defenders' own claim and condemns it; Tertullian writes as an enemy of anatomy. Whether living people were cut open is still debated.
Sources (2)
- Celsus, On Medicine prooemium 23–26, 74
- Tertullian, On the Soul 10.4